Reputed to be the oldest surviving structure in Winnebago County, this c. 1875 church retains the pews, altar, tin ceilings and flooring from when it was last used as a church. A basement was added to the structure in 1926. It was donated to the Winnebago Historical Society about 10 years ago and since then, it has hosted concerts and events and been rented out for other functions.

In recent years, however, the increasing maintenance needs of the church have become a significant financial burden for the Historical Society. One of the biggest concerns is water infiltration and the resulting mold in the 1920s basement. Since it is not currently used but once or twice a year, the Historical Society is considering its sale.